Return to Vignettes of Ancient MathematicsEuclid,

ElementsX 7©

translated by Henry Mendell (Cal. State U., L.A.)

Return to Elements X, introduction

Go to prop. 6 Go to prop. 8

Go to prop. 6 Go to prop. 8

Prop. 7: Incommensurable magnitudes do not have a ratio to one another that an arithmos has to another.

Let there be incommensurable magnitudes A, B. I say that A does not have a ratio to B that an arithmos has to an arithmos.

For if A has to B a ratio that an arithmos has to an arithmos, A will be commensurable with B. But it isnâ€™t. Therefore, A does not have to B a ratio that an arithmos has to an arithmos.

Therefore, incommensurable magnitudes do not have a ratio to one another, etc.top