Euclid, Elements I 3©
translated by Henry Mendell (Cal. State U., L.A.)

Return to Vignettes of Ancient Mathematics
Return to Elements I, introduction
Go to prop. 2 Go to prop. 4

Prop. 3: With two given, unequal straight-lines to take away from the larger a straight-line equal to the smaller.

(general diagram)

Diagrams for book 1 proposition 3, following the display, construction, and demonstration(diagram 1). Let the given two unequal straight-lines be AB, G, for which let AB be the larger.  It is, in fact, required to take away from the larger, AB, a straight-line equal to G.
(diagram 2) Let an equal to straight-line G, AD, be positioned at point A (prop. 2), (diagram 3) and with a center, A, and an extension, AD, let a circle be described, DEZ (diagram 4) And since point A is center of circle DEZ, AE is equal to AD.  But G is also equal to AD.  Therefore, each of AE, G is equal to AD.  Thus AD is equal to G. 
Therefore, with two given, unequal straight-lines, AB, G, from the larger, AB, an equal, AE, to the smaller, G,  has been taken away, just what it was required to make.

Note: the construction of circle DEZ is strictly speaking unnecessary, since it was already constructed in the construction of AD. In effect, one hides how estrablished constructions got established.

top